Sunday, 30 November 2014
Is Romeo and Juliet even about Love?
Romeo and Juliet is supposedly the greatest love story, but what if it wasn't a love story. If you look deeper and read in between the lines, you can figure out how different people perceive the same story. There have been many theories on how the story might have a broader meaning. Some being on how we are actually meant to hate Romeo, written in the Mary Sue blog by Glen Tickle.
"This love feel I, that feel no love in this", this line said by Romeo tells us how he's the only one in love in his and Rosaline relationship. She made it very clear on how she had no love towards Romeo. This backs up my prediction on how Romeo moved on to fast. According to a conversation on "ask men boards", the amount of time it takes to recover from a break up varies from months and years. Although the time wasn't clarified from when he first fell in love with Rosaline, you can clearly see how fast Romeo made the switch. It only took one glance for Romeo to fall out of love with Rosaline straight to Juliet. In modern terms we would call him a player.
LADY CAPULET- "She's not fourteen." She tells us how Juliet is not even fourteen yet, and how she is expected to get married to Paris at such a young age. Juliet being my age right now, I can relate to her feelings and emotions. We love someone but then we soon realize that it's just us being over dramatic or hormonal. Most of us haven't even experienced true love. If we haven't then how is Juliet supposed to. In her mind Romeo might be a good looking guy that wants her. In reality they are still teenagers. a lot of people are "in love with the concept of love". They want to be in love and have a happily ever after, but that's not how the world works. Teenagers have crushes but nothing compares to true love. Romeo showed how he loved Rosaline but then realized that you actually didn't even love her. This shows how teens think that something is there but it actually isn't. We are naïve and unaware of the actual meaning of love.
Juliet is a young teenager girl that is about to marry a much older man. Romeo might be her escape. She is running away from her problems by using him. People might think of Juliet as being a little girl that isn't the sharpest tool in the shed. She can be hiding behind a mask. Juliet can possibly be manipulating everyone around her. In the end she might have killed herself because her plan didn't go as planned and she didn't want to get caught. The Friar and Nurse were doing all of her dirty work. She took advantage of a desperate guy, Romeo, to benefit herself. “I’ll send a friar with speed To Mantua, with my letters to thy lord" Friar was the one to organize how the letter was going to get to Romeo. Juliet did nothing but give her consent. She kept her hands off the evidence. In the end when everyone blames Friar, he says "Doth make against me of this direful murder". He realized looking back how this looked like it was his fault. No one got mad at Juliet; they ended up making a pure gold statue of her. "For I will raise her in pure gold". Either way Juliet won in both circumstances. If Romeo lived, she would run off and live her own life away from her family.
Re-reading most of the script of Romeo and Juliet the opinions of others was starting to show. This play has so many different ideas and arguments over how if this is even about love. This wasn't based on true love but more of an perception of love. All in all depending on who you ask and how you word the question, you could get countless miss matched opinions of how Shakespeare meant to portray the play. If only he was still alive we would be able to find the answers to varies question.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
In your intro don't say "what if". You have to state your idea like your god and its the only truth. :)
ReplyDeleteAlso to add on to Joven don't say "I"
ReplyDeleteI like how you're citing your information! In formal writing you aren't supposed to be talking in first person or third person so no using things like "I"!
ReplyDeleteDon't forget to capitalize your "A" after teenagers. Your prospective of the story is really interesting especially how you wrote on how Juliet basically could have used everyone for herself, I never really thought about it that way!
ReplyDeleteGood job! Your first and third paragraphs were really strong. Just avoid using "I" like Kira said. Also check punctuation after some quotes, and change "to" to "too" in the first paragraph where is says he "moved on TOO fast" :)
ReplyDeletegood job?:) & I agree w/ Kira and Jasmine, don't use 'I' and remember to capitalize. but overall, I really liked your post:)
ReplyDeletecapitalize names.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with not using "I." This is really good! Your ideas are great and you support your ideas very well.
ReplyDeleteThanks Joven, Kira, Gaby Avery, and Jasmine for telling me about how I shouldn't use "I" in formal writing. I will fix that for my good copy! Sorry Joven I was in a rush but I will make sure I remember that for the future!
ReplyDeleteThis is a really great start Unjali. Things to improve: your thesis is good but the support in the middle loses it's way a little and I had to stop and think about what your thesis was, I think you could find even better evidence to prove you thesis, your conclusion gets all wishy washy again… stick to your thesis and finish strong (like Joven said.. pretend you're GOD). Things you did well: I really like how you wrote your citation into your paper to give the author credit for his idea, and you thesis, while jaded has huge merit and I love that you tackled it. Your formal writing is solid as well, and you have a flow to you sentences that many others in our class don't.
ReplyDelete